Location Research Breakthrough Possible @S-Logix pro@slogix.in

Remediating Prometheus Metrics Endpoint Information Disclosure Through Vulnerability Assessment and Security Configuration Validation

Description

Prometheus is an open-source monitoring and alerting system that collects and stores time-series metrics from monitored systems and applications. It provides HTTP endpoints for its web interface, API, and telemetry. The Prometheus server exposes its own `/metrics` endpoint through its HTTP service.

In this use case, a controlled Prometheus monitoring environment is deployed on an Ubuntu Linux virtual machine inside an isolated VirtualBox laboratory. Kali Linux is used as the authorized security-assessment platform.

A Node Exporter instance is deployed as a supporting metrics source. Node Exporter exposes its own `/metrics` endpoint and provides Linux host metrics that are scraped by Prometheus. Therefore, the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is the target of the vulnerability assessment, while Node Exporter is used only as the supporting metrics source.

The assessment focuses on identifying the Prometheus HTTP endpoint, validating whether the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint can be accessed without authentication, identifying the monitoring information disclosed through the endpoint, assessing the security relevance of the exposed information, and prioritizing the identified vulnerability.

The remediation workflow configures authentication and TLS protection for the Prometheus HTTP endpoints through the Prometheus web configuration file. Prometheus supports Basic Authentication and TLS through the `--web.config.file` mechanism.

After implementing the security configuration, the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is retested to verify that unauthenticated access is rejected while authorized access remains functional.

The complete vulnerability-management workflow is: Prometheus Deployment → Node Exporter Metrics Collection → Prometheus /metrics Endpoint Discovery → Unauthenticated Access Assessment → Metrics Information Identification → Vulnerability Assessment → Risk Prioritization → Authentication Configuration → TLS Configuration → Anonymous Access Retest → Authenticated Access Validation → Security Monitoring → Evidence Collection → Remediation Validation.

Existing Security Problem

Application: Prometheus Monitoring Environment

Prometheus provides the controlled monitoring environment for the vulnerability assessment. Prometheus exposes HTTP endpoints for its web interface, API, and telemetry. The Prometheus server provides its own `/metrics` endpoint. Node Exporter also provides a separate `/metrics` endpoint, but that endpoint belongs to Node Exporter and is not the target of this use case.

Existing Problem:

The security problem occurs when the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is reachable by an unauthorized user and returns monitoring information without requiring authentication. An unauthenticated user may be able to retrieve Prometheus metrics, metric names, labels, and other monitoring information exposed by the Prometheus server. The exact information available depends on the Prometheus deployment and the metrics exposed by the running Prometheus instance.

The security problem is therefore:

Prometheus Monitoring Environment → Prometheus HTTP Service → Prometheus /metrics Endpoint → Network Reachability → Unauthenticated Request → Metrics Response → Monitoring Information Disclosure → Unauthorized Information Exposure → Security Risk

The proposed solution identifies the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint, validates anonymous access, identifies the information disclosed, assesses and prioritizes the vulnerability, applies authentication and TLS protection, and validates the security configuration through post-remediation testing.

Attack

Specific Attack: Prometheus Metrics Endpoint Information Disclosure

The attack scenario represents unauthorized access to the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint when the endpoint is exposed without an authentication requirement. The authorized assessment is performed from Kali Linux against the controlled Prometheus environment. The assessment identifies the Prometheus HTTP service, discovers the `/metrics` endpoint, validates whether an unauthenticated request is accepted, retrieves the exposed metrics, identifies the disclosed monitoring information, and evaluates the resulting security risk. The controlled scenario uses the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint as the assessment target. Node Exporter `/metrics` is not treated as the attack target; it is used only to provide supporting Linux host metrics to Prometheus.

Attack Behavior:
Kali Linux / Authorized Assessor
→
Prometheus Endpoint Discovery
→
Prometheus /metrics Endpoint Discovery
→
Unauthenticated HTTP Request
→
Metrics Response
→
Exposed Metrics Identification
→
Information Disclosure Assessment
→
Vulnerability Assessment
→
Risk Prioritization
→
Authentication and TLS Remediation
→
Anonymous Access Retest
→
Protected Prometheus Endpoint
→
Access Denied
→
Authenticated Access Validation

Security Concept

Metrics Endpoint Exposure Assessment and Vulnerability Management:

The primary security concept is Prometheus metrics endpoint exposure assessment. The assessment determines whether the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is reachable from an unauthorized source and whether monitoring information can be retrieved without authentication. The second security concept is security configuration validation. The Prometheus HTTP security configuration is reviewed and validated to determine whether authentication and TLS controls are correctly applied to the Prometheus HTTP endpoints. Prometheus supports Basic Authentication and TLS through its web configuration file. The third security concept is vulnerability management, which processes the identified exposure through assessment, risk prioritization, remediation, security configuration validation, retesting, and final remediation verification.

The secure processing flow is:

Prometheus Deployment
→
Prometheus HTTP Endpoint Exposure Assessment
→
Prometheus /metrics Endpoint Discovery
→
Unauthenticated Access Testing
→
Metrics Information Retrieval
→
Information Disclosure Identification
→
Vulnerability Assessment
→
Risk Prioritization
→
Authentication/TLS Security Configuration
→
Anonymous Access Retest
→
Authenticated Access Validation
→
Security Monitoring
→
Remediation Evidence Collection
→
Final Vulnerability Validation

Defensive Mechanism

Metrics Endpoint Exposure Assessment

The Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is assessed to determine whether it is reachable from an unauthorized source.

Purpose

Identify exposed Prometheus monitoring endpoints.

Unauthenticated Access Validation

The Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is tested without providing credentials.

Purpose

Determine whether monitoring information can be retrieved without authentication.

Metrics Information Assessment

The returned Prometheus metrics are reviewed to identify the type of monitoring information exposed.

Purpose

Identify the information disclosed through unauthorized metrics access.

Information Disclosure Risk Assessment

The exposed monitoring information is evaluated based on its security relevance and exposure context.

Purpose

Determine the security significance of the identified information disclosure.

Risk Prioritization

The identified vulnerability is prioritized based on endpoint exposure, accessibility, disclosed information, and security relevance.

Purpose

Establish the remediation priority for the vulnerability.

Basic Authentication

Basic Authentication is configured for the Prometheus HTTP endpoints through the Prometheus web configuration file. Prometheus documents the use of `basic_auth_users` and the `--web.config.file` option for this protection.

Purpose

Require valid credentials before authorized users can access protected Prometheus endpoints.

TLS Protection

TLS is configured for the Prometheus HTTP service through the Prometheus web configuration file.

Purpose

Protect Prometheus HTTP communication through encrypted transport.

Configuration Validation

The Prometheus web configuration is validated before and after applying the security controls.

Purpose

Confirm that the authentication and TLS configuration is correctly structured.

Post-Remediation Access Validation

The Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is retested without credentials after remediation.

Purpose

Confirm that unauthenticated access is no longer permitted.

Authenticated Access Validation

The protected Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is accessed using valid credentials.

Purpose

Confirm that legitimate monitoring access remains functional.

Security Monitoring

Relevant security and system activity from the Prometheus environment is monitored.

Purpose

Provide security visibility into the controlled monitoring environment.

Centralized Security Investigation

Collected security evidence is correlated and investigated through the centralized security-analysis platform.

Purpose

Support vulnerability verification and remediation validation.

Security Tools

Target Monitoring Application: Prometheus

Prometheus provides the controlled monitoring environment and exposes the `/metrics` endpoint that is assessed for unauthorized information disclosure.

Purpose
  • Provide the target monitoring environment.
  • Expose the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint.
  • Collect and store monitoring metrics.
  • Apply authentication and TLS configuration.
  • Validate post-remediation access.

Metrics Exporter: Node Exporter

Node Exporter provides Linux host metrics that are scraped by Prometheus. Its `/metrics` endpoint is used as a supporting metrics source and is not the target endpoint of this use case.

Purpose
  • Provide Linux host metrics.
  • Generate realistic monitoring data.
  • Provide metrics for Prometheus to scrape.
  • Support the controlled monitoring environment.
  • Avoid making Node Exporter the assessment target.

Testing Tool: cURL

cURL is used to generate controlled HTTP and HTTPS requests against the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint.

Purpose
  • Discover endpoint responses.
  • Test unauthenticated access.
  • Validate authentication enforcement.
  • Validate HTTPS communication.
  • Perform post-remediation testing.

Configuration Validation Tool: promtool

promtool is used to validate Prometheus configuration and web configuration. Prometheus documents `promtool check web-config` for validating the web configuration file.

Purpose
  • Validate Prometheus configuration.
  • Validate web configuration.
  • Identify configuration errors.
  • Support authentication configuration validation.
  • Support remediation evidence collection.

Security Assessment Platform: Kali Linux

Kali Linux provides the authorized security-testing environment used to assess the Prometheus endpoint.

Purpose
  • Perform endpoint discovery.
  • Generate controlled HTTP requests.
  • Test unauthenticated access.
  • Validate authentication enforcement.
  • Perform post-remediation assessment.

Operating System: Ubuntu Linux

Ubuntu provides the controlled server environment hosting Prometheus and Node Exporter.

Purpose
  • Host Prometheus.
  • Host Node Exporter.
  • Store laboratory configuration.
  • Run the monitoring environment.
  • Support security monitoring.

Security Monitoring Tool: Wazuh

Wazuh provides security monitoring for the Ubuntu Prometheus environment.

Purpose
  • Monitor relevant system activity.
  • Collect security events.
  • Monitor the laboratory environment.
  • Provide security evidence.
  • Support vulnerability investigation.

Security Analytics Tool: OpenSearch

OpenSearch provides centralized investigation and correlation of collected security evidence.

Purpose
  • Search collected security events.
  • Correlate assessment activity.
  • Investigate security evidence.
  • Support remediation validation.
  • Build the vulnerability assessment timeline.

Virtualization Platform: VirtualBox

VirtualBox provides the isolated laboratory environment for the Ubuntu and Kali Linux virtual machines.

Purpose
  • Isolate the testing environment.
  • Host Prometheus and Node Exporter.
  • Host the Kali security-testing platform.
  • Provide controlled network connectivity.
  • Support repeatable vulnerability assessments.

Process

STEP 01

Step 1: Prepare the Isolated Prometheus VM Lab

  • Create the Ubuntu virtual machine for the controlled Prometheus environment.
  • Prepare the Kali Linux security-testing virtual machine.
  • Configure controlled communication between the virtual machines.
  • Allocate the required CPU, memory, storage, and network resources.
  • Verify that the laboratory environment is isolated from unauthorized systems.
Tools: VirtualBox + Ubuntu Linux + Kali Linux
STEP 02

Step 2: Deploy Prometheus

  • Install Prometheus on the Ubuntu VM.
  • Configure the Prometheus monitoring environment.
  • Start the Prometheus service.
  • Verify that the Prometheus HTTP service is operational.
  • Confirm that the Prometheus server is accessible from the authorized laboratory network.
Tools: Prometheus + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 03

Step 3: Deploy Node Exporter

  • Install Node Exporter on the Ubuntu VM.
  • Start the Node Exporter service.
  • Verify that Node Exporter exposes its `/metrics` endpoint.
  • Configure Prometheus to scrape the Node Exporter endpoint.
  • Confirm that Prometheus receives the supporting Linux host metrics.
Tools: Node Exporter + Prometheus + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 04

Step 4: Configure Prometheus to Collect Lab Metrics

  • Configure the Node Exporter target in `prometheus.yml`.
  • Verify that Prometheus can scrape the Node Exporter metrics.
  • Confirm that the target becomes available in the Prometheus monitoring environment.
  • Verify that Linux host metrics are being collected.
  • Record the normal monitoring configuration.
Tools: Prometheus + Node Exporter + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 05

Step 5: Establish Normal Prometheus Metrics Endpoint Behavior

  • Verify that Prometheus is listening on the configured HTTP address.
  • Verify that the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is available.
  • Send a normal request to the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint.
  • Record the normal HTTP response.
  • Preserve the endpoint behavior as the laboratory baseline.
Tools: Prometheus + cURL + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 06

Step 6: Establish Controlled Exposed-Endpoint Condition

  • Maintain the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint without authentication for the initial assessment.
  • Ensure that the endpoint is reachable from the authorized Kali Linux system.
  • Verify that the endpoint returns the Prometheus metrics.
  • Record the initial security configuration.
  • Preserve the condition as the vulnerability-assessment baseline.
Tools: Prometheus + Ubuntu Linux + Kali Linux + cURL
STEP 07

Step 7: Perform Prometheus Endpoint Discovery

  • Use Kali Linux as the authorized testing system.
  • Identify the Prometheus server address.
  • Identify the Prometheus HTTP service.
  • Identify the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint.
  • Confirm that the discovered `/metrics` endpoint belongs to Prometheus and not Node Exporter.
  • Record the endpoint information.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus
STEP 08

Step 8: Perform Unauthenticated Metrics Endpoint Assessment

  • Send an HTTP request to the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint without credentials.
  • Observe the HTTP response status.
  • Determine whether the endpoint accepts the unauthenticated request.
  • Retrieve the returned Prometheus metrics where access is permitted.
  • Record the endpoint response as vulnerability-assessment evidence.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus
STEP 09

Step 9: Identify Disclosed Information

  • Review the metrics returned by the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint.
  • Identify metric names and labels.
  • Identify available Prometheus runtime and monitoring information.
  • Determine the type of information accessible without authentication.
  • Record the relevant exposed information.
  • Preserve the response as assessment evidence.
Tools: cURL + Prometheus + Kali Linux
STEP 10

Step 10: Perform Vulnerability and Risk Assessment

  • Confirm that the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint is accessible without authentication.
  • Assess the security relevance of the disclosed monitoring information.
  • Evaluate the exposure scope within the controlled environment.
  • Document the vulnerability condition.
  • Record the supporting technical evidence.
  • Determine the initial risk characteristics of the finding.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus
STEP 11

Step 11: Prioritize the Finding

  • Evaluate the accessibility of the Prometheus endpoint.
  • Evaluate the type of monitoring information disclosed.
  • Evaluate the exposure context of the Prometheus HTTP service.
  • Determine the remediation priority.
  • Document the prioritization rationale.
  • Record the final vulnerability-assessment result.
Tools: Prometheus + Kali Linux + Vulnerability Assessment Process
STEP 12

Step 12: Prepare Authentication Configuration

  • Create the Prometheus web configuration file.
  • Define the authorized laboratory username.
  • Generate the required password hash.
  • Configure the Basic Authentication settings.
  • Validate the web configuration before applying it to Prometheus.
Tools: Prometheus + promtool + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 13

Step 13: Configure Prometheus Endpoint Authentication

  • Configure Prometheus to load the web configuration file.
  • Enable Basic Authentication for the Prometheus HTTP endpoints.
  • Restart or reload the Prometheus service as required.
  • Verify that the Prometheus service remains operational.
  • Confirm that the authentication configuration is active.
Tools: Prometheus + Ubuntu Linux + promtool
STEP 14

Step 14: Configure TLS

  • Generate or provide the laboratory TLS certificate and private key.
  • Configure the TLS server settings in the Prometheus web configuration.
  • Configure Prometheus to use the TLS-enabled web configuration.
  • Restart or reload the Prometheus service as required.
  • Verify that the Prometheus endpoint is available through HTTPS.
  • Record the TLS configuration as remediation evidence.
Tools: Prometheus + OpenSSL + Ubuntu Linux
STEP 15

Step 15: Perform Anonymous Access Retest

  • Send a request to the protected Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint without credentials.
  • Observe the HTTP response.
  • Confirm that anonymous access is rejected.
  • Record the authentication response.
  • Verify that the previously exposed metrics are no longer accessible without valid credentials.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus
STEP 16

Step 16: Perform Authenticated Metrics Access Validation

  • Send a request to the protected Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint using valid credentials.
  • Verify successful authentication.
  • Confirm that the Prometheus metrics can be retrieved.
  • Verify that legitimate monitoring access remains functional.
  • Record the authenticated response as remediation evidence.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus
STEP 17

Step 17: Perform Security Monitoring and Evidence Collection

  • Monitor the Ubuntu Prometheus environment for relevant security activity.
  • Collect applicable system and security events.
  • Forward available security evidence to Wazuh.
  • Review the collected events.
  • Preserve relevant evidence associated with the vulnerability assessment and remediation.
Tools: Wazuh + Ubuntu Linux + Prometheus
STEP 18

Step 18: Investigate Security Evidence

  • Review the collected security events.
  • Correlate endpoint-assessment activity with the Prometheus environment.
  • Analyze evidence associated with unauthenticated access attempts.
  • Analyze evidence associated with authenticated access.
  • Review the remediation activity.
  • Preserve the investigation evidence for final validation.
Tools: Wazuh + OpenSearch + Prometheus
STEP 19

Step 19: Perform Final Vulnerability Assessment and Remediation Validation

  • Repeat the Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint assessment.
  • Confirm that unauthenticated access remains blocked.
  • Confirm that authenticated access remains functional.
  • Verify that TLS protection is active.
  • Validate the final Prometheus web configuration.
  • Confirm that the original information-disclosure condition has been remediated.
  • Document the final remediation evidence.
  • Close the vulnerability finding after successful validation.
Tools: Kali Linux + cURL + Prometheus + promtool + Wazuh + OpenSearch

Outcome

  1. A controlled Prometheus monitoring environment was deployed with Ubuntu Linux and Node Exporter as the supporting metrics source.
  2. The Prometheus `/metrics` endpoint was identified and assessed as the specific target of the vulnerability assessment.
  3. Unauthenticated metrics endpoint exposure was identified through controlled HTTP endpoint testing.
  4. Prometheus monitoring information disclosure was assessed and prioritized based on endpoint exposure and the information returned.
  5. Basic Authentication was configured to restrict unauthorized access to Prometheus HTTP endpoints.
  6. TLS protection was configured and validated for protected Prometheus HTTP communication.
  7. Unauthenticated access was rejected after remediation, demonstrating that the original anonymous-access condition had been removed.
  8. Authenticated Prometheus metrics access remained functional, confirming that legitimate monitoring access was preserved.
  9. Security evidence was collected and investigated through Wazuh and OpenSearch to support vulnerability verification and remediation validation.
  10. The complete vulnerability-management lifecycle was demonstrated, covering endpoint discovery, vulnerability assessment, risk prioritization, remediation, security configuration validation, retesting, security monitoring, evidence correlation, and final remediation verification.
← Previous Project
Project 7 of 7